They had a substitute teacher for Junior's 2nd grade class on Monday. Yesterday teacher gets a report from sub that on Monday Junior was "being disruptive by trying to instruct other students instead of letting the teacher do her job." This would not be the first time this sort of thing has happened - last year, the first grade teacher reported having the same problem at the beginning of the school year. Teacher asks Junior about the reported behavior on Monday with the substitute and he reportedly started to admit to it, but when teacher says she will be sending home a behavior referral note to parents, he quickly reverses course and states he has no idea what the sub is talking about. When parents confront him about the referral note, Junior steadfastly maintains his innocence, stating he has 'no idea' why substitute would be making such allegations. Parents know damned well he is lying, but of course do not have direct proof. When parents suggest they should ask classmates (who would be at Cub Scouts last night) about Monday's events, Junior blithely says 'go ahead' (at Cub Scout meeting said classmates claim to have no recollection of the distant and hazy events of yesterday). When parents suggest they may wish to see the "tape" of Monday's class (there is no such recording, but Junior probably doesn't know that) and offer Junior one last chance to come clean he defiantly states 'yes, do that.'
Neither parent is particularly concerned about the behavior referral itself, but Parent A thinks it's maybe important for Junior to think his parents believe him when he tells them something and wants to hold off on punishment. Parent B thinks Junior is testing parents/engaging in brinksmanship and wants to punish the ever loving hell outta him for lying.
What does the Throbbing Brain suggest?