How did I miss this comment? I've always been taught that oxygen is the mortal enemy of wine in the bottle. Here's a test you can perform at home: open a bottle, pour a glass, re-cork the bottle, and leave the poured glass of wine uncovered for 24-hours on your counter. The next day, pour a second glass for the bottle. Taste the two and compare. You be the judge. I rest my case.
Unless convinced otherwise by reputable sources, I will defer to the winery owners and wine makers that I have spoken to concerning this topic. Again, oxygen is the mortal enemy of wine.
Yes, my point exactly. I am not disagreeing with you on that. Oxygen causes the wine to age. Temperature causes the wine to age. UV light causes the wine to age. Wine loss, caused by faulty corks and humidity cause a wine to age. If you put a bottle of wine in a vacuum at 55 degrees, the wine would probably taste similar to what it does today in 10 years. I do not know any wine makers or wine owners who have built themselves a vacuum. Why is this? (Other than the pure inability and cost of doing it....)
Aging is what makes the wine more complex. Oxygen, temperature, humidity are part of that equation.
While synthetic corks may help a wine not evaporate, it does nothing to stop oxydation. It has been shown that synthetic corks actually let in MORE oxygen than natural corks
over time.
Aging is not for every wine. But for those wines that have the right stuff, I would bottle them with a natural cork. Again, for the short term, I have no issues with synthetic or screwcap. There are plenty of good wines with each enclosure. But for aging, natural cork is best.
What I said was that if you want to keep a bottle of wine longer use a natural cork. Maiser asked if a wine would get more complex with a synthetic cork. My answer still stands and is supported by most enologists. The wine will age faster- go bad faster- and not last as long with a synthetic cork. Therefore the wine will not have the opportunity to get more complex. Sure it might get more complex than it was originally, but studies have shown that synthetic corks are not as good at aging (and therefore making wine more complex) than natural corks.
I rest my case
Also a good read by some scientist guy, about aging wine.
Here
I am not sure why you thought I didn't agree with you that oxygen is bad for wine? I just was comparing the synthetic cork to the natural cork. :-$