We have a "tech" position that I have recast over the years as more of an entry-level planner position, although it is admin-heavy. I don't think a straight admin would do well because if you're not into planning it's just going to be drudgery. Anyway, here's my "round 1" questions and a scoring rubric (we look at how many of the five elements the candidate puts into their answer). The whole decision is in no way based on the score but it has let me take a pile of 6-7 first-round interviewees and pick 2-3 for follow-ups.
Round 1:
Planning Tech Recruitment- Round 1, target is for a 30-minute interview but we have about 50 minutes budgeted if we need it. Introductions- Staff, Candidate etc. Staff Introduces themselves to candidate and candidate does the same (5 minutes) Structured questions to be asked of each candidate
Questions and suggested scores for answers (0-5 points, 1 point for a solid answer to each of the answer elements below for a max of 5) (4 minutes per question, 20 minutes total)
The planning technician position in XXXXX is an entry-level planning job that involves a chance to work on some interesting projects- in balance with a steady load of more administrative tasks and evening meetings. Based on what you know about the town and the position, please describe your motivation to work in this position.
1. Interest in a planning technician position
2. Specific interest in working in XXXX
3. Willingness to do administrative tasks
4. Willingness to work as a team member on other projects
5. Understanding of time and night meeting schedule commitment.
Based on your prior work, class and/or internship experiences, what skills do you anticipate using in the planning technician position? What might be a challenge? What skills would you want to develop to meet that challenge?
1. Discusses prior work, internship, or class experiences
2. Identifies skills developed in other environments (work, internship, class)
3. Connects those skills and experiences to planning technician position
4. Identifies what might be personally or professionally challenging about the position
5. Identifies skills the candidate would like to add or develop
Describe a situation where you experienced the failure of a project or effort you were involved in- how did you handle it? What did you learn from it? How would you handle a similar situation as a planning technician in XXXXXX?
1. Identifies a âfailure.â
2. Explains consequences or potential consequences of failure
3. Explains what they did to âfixâ it
4. Identifies what they learned from the âfailure.â
5. Applies âfailureâ experience to planning tech position.
How does this position fit in your expected career path? What about being a planning technician makes this position a good element of that path? Is there anything about XXXXXXXXX specifically that makes this a good fit?
1. Connects education/ work background and this position
2. Identifies experiences candidate wants out of the position
3. Shows understanding of where the position could lead
4. Is realistic about the limitations for advancement in this position (i.e. we are not looking for someone who wants to be the tech the rest of their career, and we want our candidates to be honest rather than saying this!)
5. Identifies specific areas where looking for more experience
Bonus question (1-5 points): Youâre talking with the XXXXXX Planning Director- Is there anything youâve observed about XXXXX that you want to know more about?
1. Is curious about/has observed something in XXXXXX
2. That something is at least tangentially planning-related
3. Has thought about potential answers to their question
4. Response from the candidate: (âthatâs interesting, in other places Iâve seen that happen this way, or âI studied something like that in college,â etc.)
5. Other intangibles?